Utica First Insurance Company


Utica First Insurance Company, located near Utica, NY, is a regional property and casualty insurance carrier specializing in small contractors, restaurants, retail stores, offices, and homeowners insurance. We operate in New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Virginia.

A.M. Best Rating

This company was issued a secure rating by the A.M. Best Company, click for additional details
As of May 6, 2009, our A.M. Best rating is A (Excellent). For more information, view the A.M. Best Press Release.

Utica First Insurance named to the 2013 Ward's 50 Top Performers

June 27th, 2014, Utica First Insurance was named for the second consecutive year to the Ward's Top 50 performers making back to back appearances in the 2013 Ward's 50 Top Performers and the 2014 Ward's 50 Top Performer.

Utica First Insurance awarded 2013 Stakeholder Team Accomplishment Recognition Award

Utica First Insurance Company has been awarded a 2013 Stakeholder Team Accomplishment Recognition™ (STAR) award from Demotech, Inc. for its operating results in 2012, as verified in its June 30, 2013 statutory quarterly statement.

What's New?

Online Artisan Survey - Click here to access the online survey

Online Artisan Survey
Artisan policyholders can complete their required survey through our Online Artisan Survey. This program is available for all new artisan policyholders as of October 1, 2009 and existing policyholders that renew on or after January 28, 2010. All other artisan policyholders should continue to call our Artisan Survey Unit at 1-800-456-4556 Option 1 to complete their survey.

Online Bill Pay - Click here to make a one time payment!

We now accept payment by check, credit card, and debit card over the Internet. See our Billing Inquiry page for more information.

Pay online by check, credit card, or debit card.