Please be advised that Utica First Insurance will be upgrading our phone system at 4pm on Thursday August 13. We will be unable to send or receive calls during this upgrade. We apologize for the inconvenience and thank you for your understanding
Branding Accent

Putting You First

Insurance can often feel like a commodity, but that’s never been Utica First. The way the organization treats agents/brokers, policyholders and employees – no one has ever been a number. For decades, the organization and its leadership has built and maintained trusted and valued relationships. The updated look reinforces that it is the people behind the Utica First brand that make it one of a kind.

Putting You First

Utica First's President / CEO
Learn more about Utica First.

For over
100 years

Utica First Insurance Company has been providing superior insurance protection to Homeowners and Businesses in Connecticut, Florida, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia. We are a strong and stable Regional Insurance Company, rated as A (Excellent) by A.M. Best, with a proud tradition of customer service excellence.

Our History
Contact
Us
Call
800-456-4556