Find An Agent Agents & Brokers Community Pay My Bill

800-456-4556
Home
Find An Agent
Agents
Brokers
My Policy
Payment Options
Pay My Bill
Our Products
Claims
Careers
About
Resources
My Policy
Report A Claim
Contact Us

Home Site Map

Site Map

Utica First Insurance Company

Home
Commercial Insurance
Personal Insurance

Claims
Careers
About
Community
Contact Us

Agents
Brokers
My Policy
Payment Options
Pay My Bill

Find An Agent By:

or

Distance: within 15 miles

States we serve: CT, FL, MA, MD, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA

My Policy

Unique, cost effective commercial insurance products for small and medium sized businesses.

View Policy
View more

Payment Options

Unique, cost effective commercial insurance products for small and medium sized businesses.

View Options
View more

Phone: 800-456-4556
Direct: 315-736-8211
General Fax: 315-768-4408
Accounting Fax: 315-736-1836
Claims Fax: 315-736-2139
General Email: Email Us

Home
Commercial Insurance
Personal Insurance
Claims

Careers
About
Community
Contact

Agents & Brokers
Report A Claim
My Policy
Payment Options
Pay My Bill

All Rights Reserved. © 2025 Utica First Insurance Company. Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Sitemap
a Quadsimia website proudly made in Upstate NY.

Contact
Us Call
800-456-4556

Utica First Insurance Company Appoints Fleming as Next President and CEO

Utica First Insurance Company Appoints Fleming as Next President and CEO

Utica First Insurance Company announces the appointment of Ryan Fleming as President and CEO, effective January 1, 2026. Fleming will succeed retiring President and CEO Scott Shatraw.

Read Press Release

No, thanks. Continue to website.